AI Search
GEO Myths Worth Ignoring Before You Waste Money
By Mohamed Eltoukhy, founder of EVOGENCY ·
Because generative engine optimization is new, it's already attracting overconfident claims and made up certainty about a field that's still genuinely being figured out, including by the AI companies themselves.
Here are the claims we'd ignore, and what actually deserves your time and money.
Nobody can guarantee a mention
Any service claiming they can guarantee your business will be named by ChatGPT or Google AI Overviews is overselling something nobody, including those companies, has fully cracked yet.
AI answers vary by question, by user, and over time. Anyone promising a fixed result is guessing, or hoping you won't check.
It's an addition, not a replacement
GEO builds on the same foundation as regular SEO. Anyone suggesting it replaces the fundamentals of a good website and real local presence is skipping the actual groundwork.
Google has said plainly that optimizing for its AI features is still SEO, and that its AI results are rooted in the same core ranking systems.
Myth: you need a special AI file
Some services sell special text files meant to tell AI tools about your business. Google says its search doesn't use them. They're not harmful, but they're not a substitute for clear content on your actual pages.
Myth: you need to write for robots
Content stuffed with keyword variations or split into tiny fragments for AI reads badly to humans and doesn't earn you anything special. Google's guidance is to write for people, at the length the topic genuinely needs.
Myth: fake mentions will work
Planting your business name across low quality sites or forums to trick AI into recommending you is the same kind of manipulation search engines have fought for years. It risks penalties and damages trust when people notice.
Myth: AI search makes local SEO obsolete
People still need to call, book, and visit local businesses. Google Business Profiles, reviews, and accurate listings remain central to how businesses get recommended, whether the answer comes from a map, a list of links, or an AI summary.
What actually helps
Clear pages that answer real questions, accurate and consistent business information, genuine reviews, original expertise, and a technically sound website. That's unglamorous, and it's what works.
How to judge a GEO pitch
Ask what specific work they'll do, how they'll measure it, and what's different from good SEO. Honest providers will admit the field is young and focus on fundamentals. That's exactly how we approach our own generative engine optimization service.
Keep reading
Related guides
ChatGPT Search vs. Perplexity vs. Google AI Overviews: What's Actually Different
A plain language comparison of the major AI search tools, and what each means for a local business.
Read moreHow AI Overviews Are Changing Local Search
How Google's AI Overviews are changing the local search results page, and what it means for local businesses.
Read moreWhat Generative Engine Optimization Means for Your Business
A plain language explanation of GEO, how it differs from regular SEO, and why it's worth thinking about now.
Read more